| P | W | D | L | F | A | |
| Friendlies | 21 | 6 | 3 | 12 | 44 | 54 |
| FA Cup | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 2 |
| SA Cup | 3 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 7 | 3 |
| WCC | 5 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 6 |
| Total | 31 | 11 | 5 | 15 | 56 | 65 |
| 1884-85 | |||||
| venue | att | score | |||
| SA Cup | |||||
| 11-Oct | Hallam | Bramall Lane | large | 5-1 | W |
| 10-Nov | Attercliffe | Bramall Lane | large | 2-1 | W |
| 6-Dec | Lockwood Brothers | Bramall Lane | 3/4000 | 0-1 | L |
| WCC | |||||
| Mexborough | W | ||||
| 28-Feb | Lockwood Brothers | Old Forge | good | 1-1 | D |
| 14-Mar | Lockwood Brothers | Bramall Lane | 3000 | 1-0 | W |
| 28-Mar | Heeley | Bramall Lane | 5000 | 1-1 | D |
| 6-Apr | Heeley | Bramall Lane | 5/6000 | 0-4 | L |
| FA Cup | |||||
| 8-Nov | Long Eaton Rangers | Flats,Long Eaton | v.large | 1-0 | W |
| Notts Forest | Bramall Lane | 3000 | 1-2 | L | |
| Friendly | |||||
| 20-Sep | Spital | Hunter's Bar | good | 2-1 | W |
| 20-Sep | Aston Villa | Perry Bar | large | 3-2 | W |
| 27-Sep | Bolton Wanderers | Pikes Lane | 3000 | 1-2 | L |
| 4-Oct | Mexborough | Bramall Lane | numerous | 5-1 | W |
| 18-Oct | Notts County | Trent Bridge | 2000 | 0-0 | D |
| 27-Oct | Heeley | Bramall Lane | 1000 | 1-1 | D |
| 1-Nov | Notts County | Bramall Lane | 2000 | 0-1 | L |
| 15-Nov | Notts Forest | Parkside | 600 | 5-0 | W |
| 22-Nov | Blackburn Rovers | Leamington Road | not large | 1-3 | L |
| 22-Nov | Spital | Chesterfield | ? | 2-3 | L |
| 30-Nov | Blackburn Olympic | Blackburn | 0-12 | L | |
| 20-Dec | Blackburn Rovers | Bramall Lane | 1500 | 1-3 | L |
| 10-Jan | Astley Bridge | Astley Bridge | 1000 | 3-1 | W |
| 17-Jan | Mexborough | Mexbro' | large | 2-2 | D |
| 26-Jan | Bolton Wanderers | Bramall Lane | small | 2-6 | L |
| 26-Jan | Heeley | Bramall Lane | 1000 | 0-3 | L |
| 21-Feb | Preston | Deepdale | 1-8 | L | |
| 30-Mar | Aston Villa | Bramall Lane | 600 | 1-2 | L |
| 4-Apr | Notts Forest | Bramall Lane | 0-7 | L | |
| 11-Apr | Lockwood Brothers | Ecclesall Road | less num | 3-2 | W |
| Preston | Bramall Lane | 0-4 | L | ||
| 27-Apr | Heeley | Bramall Lane | p.p. |