Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
| P | W | D | L | F | A | |
| Friendlies | 13 | 8 | 3 | 2 | 29 | 8 |
| Total | 13 | 8 | 3 | 2 | 29 | 8 |
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
| 1873-74 | |||||
| venue | score | ||||
| First Team | |||||
| 7-Oct | Attercliffe | Attercliffe | 4-0 | W | |
| 14-Oct | Heeley | Meersbrook Park | |||
| 28-Oct | Broomhall | Myrtle Road | 2-2 | D | |
| 11-Nov | Exchange Brewery | Myrtle Road | 5-0 | W | Called Tennant Brothers Brewery in reports |
| 22-Nov | Fir Vale | Myrtle Road | 0-0 | D | |
| 2-Dec | Heeley | Myrtle Road | 3-1 | W | |
| 16-Jan | Rotherham | Rotherham | 0-1 | L | |
| 29-Jan | Derbyshire | Bramall Lane | 6-0 | W | |
| 13-Jan | Rotherham | Myrtle Road | 2-0 | W | Rotherham kicked towards the 'castle' |
| 20-Jan | Attercliffe | Myrtle Road | 1-0 | W | |
| 3-Feb | Broomhall | Ecclesall Road | 1-2 | L | |
| 10-Feb | Fir Vale | Shirecliffe Lane | 2-1 | W | The ground was very uneven, dipped toward the goal. |
| 3-Mar | Derbyshire | Derwent R.C. | 0-0 | D | |
| 14-Mar | Norfolk | Myrtle Road | 3-1 | W | |
| Second Team | |||||
| 18-Oct | Fir Vale | Shirecliffe Lane | 5-0 | W | |
| 15-Nov | Norfolk | Norfolk Park | 2-5 | L | |
| 1-Dec | Broomhall | Ecclesall Road | 0-0 | D | |
| 6-Dec | Rotherham | Rotherham | 1-1 | D | |
| 22-Jan | Broomhall | Myrtle Road | 2-1 | W | Broomhall kicked from Myrtle Road downhill |
| 27-Jan | Norfolk | Norfolk Park | 1-3 | L | |
| 24-Feb | Norfolk | Myrtle Road | 4-1 | W | |
| Third Team | |||||
| 12-Feb | Broomhall | Ecclesall Road | 1-1 | D |
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context
Notes | Summary | League | Cup | Friendlies | Players | Context